The High-Stakes Game of Executive Selection: How Hogan Assessments Can Transform Your Hiring Decisions

When Great Interviews Lead to Disastrous Hires

Here's a scenario that keeps CEOs and boards awake at night: Six months after hiring that charismatic, impressive executive who aced every interview, your client calls with the bad news. Their new hire has alienated half the leadership team, pushed through decisions that clash with company culture, and now they're facing the excruciating prospect of starting the search all over again.

The financial cost? Enormous. The opportunity cost? Even worse. The hit to company morale and momentum? Potentially devastating.

This isn't a hypothetical. This happens every day in companies of all sizes, and it happens for one fundamental reason: traditional hiring methods—no matter how many rounds of interviews or reference checks—simply cannot reveal how executives will actually perform once they're in the role and under pressure.

So what's the solution? That's where I come in.

A Science-Backed Approach to Reducing Executive Hiring Risk

With an educational background in the behavioral sciences and over 25 years dedicated to organizational development, I've witnessed firsthand how the right—or wrong—executive can transform a company's trajectory.

When it comes to high-stakes executive hires, I believe we need more than gut instinct. We need science. And that's precisely what the Hogan Assessment System delivers.

Think of it this way: If you were building a bridge, you wouldn't just eyeball the materials and hope it holds up during rush hour. You'd use engineering principles, stress tests, and proven methodologies. Why should building your executive team be any different?

Why Growing Companies Need More Than Interviews

For fast-growing startups especially—where I've focused much of my consulting work in the last several years—the consequences of a poor executive hire can be particularly severe. When you're scaling rapidly, you don't have the organizational cushion to absorb the impact of leadership misalignment.

Here's what traditional interview processes frequently miss:

The Executive Under Pressure: How does this polished, articulate candidate behave when things go sideways? Do they become dictatorial? Withdraw? Blame others?

True Cultural Fit: Beyond just saying the right things about your company values, will this person's deep motivations and work-style mesh with your organization?

Team Dynamics: How will this leader's particular constellation of traits and preferred workstyles complement—or clash with—your existing leadership team?

Hidden Motivations: What really drives this person? Is it achievement, recognition, power, security, or something else entirely?

The Hogan Assessment System addresses precisely these blind spots—not with hunches or impressions, but with scientifically validated metrics that predict on-the-job behavior.

The Science Behind the Hogan Difference

What makes Hogan uniquely powerful is its strong scientific foundation. Unlike many assessment tools, Hogan was developed specifically for business applications. It builds upon psychology's well-established Big Five factor model—OCEAN (Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, and Neuroticism)—but doesn't stop there.

The Hogan system adapts and extends this model with two additional scales that are crucial for workplace success: Inquisitiveness and Learning Approach. These dimensions help predict how individuals approach novel situations and acquire new knowledge—factors that are increasingly critical in today's rapidly changing business environments.

This business-focused adaptation makes Hogan significantly more relevant for predicting actual job performance than generic personality assessments. By measuring not just how people typically behave, but how they learn, adapt, and satisfy their curiosity, the Hogan system provides deeper insights into leadership potential and long-term executive success.

The Three-Dimensional Portrait of Leadership

Unlike simplistic personality tests, the Hogan system creates a sophisticated, three-dimensional portrait of each candidate through complementary assessments:

1. The Hogan Personality Inventory (HPI) reveals day-to-day leadership style, measuring seven key dimensions that predict how someone works, leads, and interacts with others.

2. The Hogan Development Survey (HDS) uncovers potential “derailers"—strengths that become weaknesses under pressure. This is critical because most leadership failures stem not from lack of ability but from these behavioral tendencies that emerge during times of stress.

3. The Motives, Values, Preferences Inventory (MVPI) identifies what truly motivates a person—their core values

and drivers. These of course are important for assessing likelihood of cultural fit and long-term satisfaction.

Together, these assessments create a comprehensive leadership profile that predicts far more accurately than interviews alone how a candidate will actually perform in your client's organization.

The ROI of Getting It Right the First Time

Let's talk bottom line. What's the cost of a failed executive hire?

Research shows the direct cost typically ranges from 2-3 times the executive's annual salary. For a $250,000 executive, that's $500,000-$750,000 down the drain.

But the true cost goes far beyond these figures:

Lost momentum on strategic initiatives
Damaged team cohesion and morale
Disrupted client and stakeholder relationships
Time and focus diverted to managing the problem and finding a replacement
Opportunity costs of what might have been accomplished with the right leader

For a growing startup where speed and execution are everything, these costs can be existential threats.

Now compare that to the investment in a rigorous assessment process—typically between $3,000-$5,000 per executive search. The return on that investment becomes obvious when you consider that science-based selection can dramatically reduce the risk of a costly hiring mistake.

The RPC Executive Assessment Process: Bringing Science to Selection

My approach integrates the Hogan Assessment System into your executive search process in a way that enhances rather than complicates the candidate experience. While this process may vary some client to client, here's how we would typically work together:

1. Setting the Foundation

We begin by understanding what success looks like in three dimensions:

Role requirements: What specific competencies and behaviors are needed?
Team dynamics: What strengths and styles already exist on the team, and what's missing?
Organizational culture: What values and working styles thrive in this environment?

This involves dedicated sessions with both:

Your recruiting team to align on process integration
The client's hiring team to deeply understand their needs

At this stage, we're creating a multi-dimensional success profile against which candidates will be measured.

2. Assessment Administration

After final candidates have been selected, they complete the three Hogan inventories online at their convenience. I meet personally with each candidate beforehand to briefly

RPC Hogan Selection Process (website).png

explain the purpose and process, ensuring they understand this is a standard part of executive selection, not an unusual hurdle.

The three assessments typically take about an hour to complete.

3. Analysis and Interpretation

This is where my expertise as a certified Hogan interpreter/coach comes in. I analyze each candidate's profile in depth, identifying:

Leadership strengths and how they align with role requirements
Potential challenge areas under pressure
Values alignment with the organization
Complementarity with the existing team

I then prepare summary reports with specific insights and interview recommendations tailored to each candidate.

4. Strategic Alignment with Your Team

Before presenting to the client, I meet with your recruiting team to:

Share key assessment findings
Integrate insights with what you've observed in interviews
Develop a cohesive narrative about each candidate
Prepare strategic interview questions for the next round

This ensures we present a unified, well-rounded perspective to the client.

5. Client Consultation

In a focused session with the client hiring team, I present insights on each candidate, covering:

Their natural leadership style and strengths
How they're likely to operate under pressure
Their core motivators and values
Potential areas to probe in final interviews
How they might complement or challenge the existing team

This isn't about labeling candidates as “good” or “bad,” but providing a deeper understanding of how each might function in the role and organization.

6. Candidate Feedback (Optional)

As an optional value-add, I offer a feedback session to each candidate assessed. This:

Provides valuable personal development insights
Creates a positive candidate experience regardless of outcome
Demonstrates the client organization's commitment to professional development

For the selected candidate, this session can serve as a powerful onboarding tool, highlighting strengths to leverage and potential challenge areas to manage proactively.

A Juggler's Perspective on Leadership Assessment

As you may not know, I paid my way through college as a professional juggler, often performing in teams. It taught me something critical that applies perfectly to executive selection: what looks effortless to the audience requires a great deal of planning and precision behind the scenes—assessment, preparation, and execution.

When for example a team of jugglers adds dangerous new elements to their routine—say, knives or torches—they don't just throw them in and hope for the best. They carefully evaluate how these elements will interact with the existing “pattern” of their performance. Before going live, they anticipate potential technical problems, assess each team member's readiness to handle them, and the team’s collective ability to manage this new task.

Executive hiring deserves the same careful approach. The Hogan assessments help us see how a new executive is likely to interact with your client's existing organizational “pattern” before they're thrown into the mix—potentially preventing a dangerous mismatch that could burn the whole team.

Ready to Transform Your Executive Selection Process?

I work with select recruiting firms who recognize that in today's competitive market, the old ways of selecting executives simply aren't enough.

If you're ready to:

Dramatically reduce the risk of expensive hiring mistakes
Provide greater value to your clients through science-based selection
Differentiate your firm with a more sophisticated, proven approach

Let's talk about how we can work together to transform your executive selection process. Contact me at russ@russpowell.com or 707-324-3122.

When the stakes are this high, can you afford not to use every advantage science can offer?

lmp banner image #3_edited_edited_edited.jpg

Join us for Leadership and the Middle Path

Our workshop, Leadership and the Middle Path—the first in the middle path curriculum—lays the perfect foundation for leadership development across your organization.

Check it out, and bring your team to our next series.